A Systemic View of Systems Theories

A Framework for Comparing Systems Theories and Teachings

Research paper: Comparison of Twelve Systems Theories Using a Systemic Framework
Template: Framework for Comparing Systems Theories and Teachings

The Frameworks:

Troncale's Systems Processes Theory
Mobus' Mathematical Framework for Systemness
Rasmussen's Intro to Systems Processes Theory
McNaughton's General Systems Theory Conceptual Framework
Challoner's Framework for a General Systems Theory
Kinneman's Relational Holon Theory
Cabrera's DSRP-483 Theory of Organization

Here you can find a simple framework for describing a systems theory and its application to thirteen theories. Please contact us to submit your’s!

Comparing theories by first looking at their concepts seems logical, but it leads to confusion. Needed, ironically, is a more systemic way to look at systems theories.

Instead, first consider context: the author’s worldview, the scope of the theory, and what the intent of the theory is. What kinds of problems does it address? What does it include that is missing in other theories? Then consider its structure and its word usage/terminology. After putting the theory or teaching into this framework, concepts can be compared.

These frameworks are works in progress. The framework template and the frameworks posted have “last updated” fields, and may be updated in the near future. — Lynn Rasmussen

Smith’s Meta-Framework for Organizing Transversal Knowledge About Systems
System Dynamics
Complex Systems Science
Critical Systems Theory
Cybernetics
Systemology